Is Mexico Safe? - Debunking Safety Myths with Real Data

Yes, Mexico is generally safe for tourists and expats, with Mexico City having lower homicide rates than several major US cities like Baltimore, St. Louis, and Detroit. Safety varies dramatically by region, Yucatán, Querétaro, and Mexico City are very safe with crime rates comparable to European countries, while states like Guerrero, Michoacán, and northern border areas have serious cartel-related violence. Tourist areas in Cancun, Playa del Carmen, Puerto Vallarta, and San Miguel de Allende remain insulated from cartel activity due to economic interests in maintaining tourism. Use common sense precautions and research specific regions before traveling.

The Data Tells a Different Story

Let's start with actual crime statistics rather than sensationalized media coverage.

Mexico City Isn't on the List

When you look at lists of the world's most dangerous cities by homicide rate, Mexico City doesn't appear. It's not in the top 10, top 20, or even top 50. Yet multiple large American cities do make these lists.

Cities like Baltimore, St. Louis, Detroit, and New Orleans consistently rank among the world's most dangerous cities by homicide rate. Mexico City's homicide rate is lower than several major U.S. cities.

The Trends

Here's what makes this even more interesting: Mexico's murder rate has been trending downward in recent years, while the United States' murder rate has been increasing.

This doesn't mean Mexico doesn't have serious crime problems—it does, particularly in certain states and regions affected by cartel violence. But it does mean that the blanket characterization of Mexico as universally dangerous is statistically inaccurate.

Regional Variations Matter Enormously

One of the biggest mistakes people make when talking about safety in Mexico is treating the entire country as a monolith. Mexico is a huge, diverse country with enormous regional variation in safety.

Safe Regions

Mexico City, despite its size (over 20 million people in the metropolitan area), has relatively low violent crime rates compared to many major world cities. Certain states like Yucatán and Querétaro have crime rates comparable to or lower than many European countries.

Dangerous Regions

States like Guerrero, Michoacán, Sinaloa, and parts of the northern border region have serious safety issues related to cartel activity and organized crime. The U.S. State Department issues travel advisories for these specific regions, and those advisories reflect real risks.

Tourist Infrastructure

Even in states with cartel presence, tourist areas are often insulated from violence. The cartels have economic interests in maintaining tourism infrastructure—violence that affects tourists is bad for business. This doesn't mean these areas are completely safe, but it does mean the risk profile is different than media coverage might suggest.

Personal Experience: Feeling Safer in Mexico City Than New York

This is going to sound counterintuitive to people who haven't lived here, but I genuinely feel safer walking the streets of Mexico City at night than I did walking around certain parts of New York or other major U.S. cities.

Visible Security Presence

Mexico City operates somewhat like a police state in terms of visible security presence. There are police and security personnel everywhere—on street corners, in metro stations, patrolling neighborhoods. This visible presence acts as a deterrent to street crime.

Neighborhood Dynamics

The neighborhoods where I've lived and spent time—Colonia Juárez, Roma, Condesa, Polanco—have active street life, people out at all hours, and a community presence that makes them feel safe. There are restaurants, cafes, and shops open late, creating natural surveillance.

The Random Violence Question

One of my biggest concerns in U.S. cities, particularly in recent years, has been random violence—someone having a mental health crisis, drug-related incidents, random assaults. In Mexico City, I feel less concerned about these random encounters, perhaps because the visible security presence deters them or because social dynamics are different.

Media Coverage and Perception

The disconnect between actual crime statistics and public perception of safety in Mexico is largely driven by media coverage patterns.

Selective Coverage

U.S. media extensively covers crime in Mexico while underreporting comparable crime in U.S. cities. A cartel-related killing in Mexico gets front-page coverage, while another weekend of shootings in Chicago gets brief local mentions.

This creates a perception that Mexico is uniquely dangerous when the statistical reality doesn't support that characterization.

The "If It Bleeds, It Leads" Problem

Sensational crime stories generate engagement and clicks. "Mexico is dangerous" fits existing narratives and confirms biases, so those stories get amplified while stories about everyday safety and normalcy don't.

What Actually Matters for Safety

After ten years here, here's what I've learned actually affects safety in Mexico City:

Neighborhood Selection

Where you live and spend time matters enormously. The neighborhoods popular with expats—Roma, Condesa, Polanco, Coyoacán, parts of Cuauhtémoc—are generally very safe. Other areas of the city have different risk profiles.

Standard Urban Precautions

The safety advice for Mexico City is the same as for any major city:

• Don't walk around visibly intoxicated late at night
• Don't flash expensive jewelry or electronics
• Be aware of your surroundings
• Use registered taxis or ride-sharing apps rather than hailing cabs on the street
• Don't wander into unfamiliar neighborhoods alone at night

This is basic urban safety, not Mexico-specific danger.

Cartel Violence vs. Street Crime

Cartel violence is real and serious, but it's generally not random. It's targeted, it's usually in specific regions, and it rarely affects foreign tourists or expats who aren't involved in drug trafficking.

Street crime—pickpocketing, bag snatching, occasional muggings—exists in Mexico City as in any major city. It's not worse than comparable cities, and with standard precautions, it's quite avoidable.

Important Context and Caveats

I don't want to minimize real safety concerns. Mexico does have serious crime problems:

Cartel Violence Is Real

In certain states and regions, cartel violence creates genuine danger. Journalists, activists, and locals caught in the crossfire face real risks. The violence is horrific and destabilizing.

But this violence is geographically concentrated and rarely random. Understanding where these risks exist is crucial to making informed decisions.

Corruption and Impunity

One of Mexico's serious problems is the low solve rate for crimes and the corruption within law enforcement. This creates a permissive environment for criminal activity in ways that are genuinely problematic.

Gender Dynamics

Women face different safety considerations in Mexico City than men, particularly around harassment and femicide rates that are horrifyingly high. This is a serious social problem that deserves recognition.

Comparing Cities Honestly

When Americans ask if Mexico City is safe, I often ask them to honestly assess the safety of their own cities.

Is it safe to walk around downtown Baltimore? Parts of Chicago? Certain neighborhoods in Oakland or St. Louis? We accept these as "normal" urban dangers in the United States but characterize similar dynamics in Mexico as evidence of the country being a dangerous hellscape.

The double standard is striking.

What the Numbers Say

Mexico City has:

• Lower homicide rates than several major U.S. cities
• Extensive security infrastructure and visible police presence
• Neighborhoods with vibrant, safe street life
• Standard urban crime that's comparable to other major world cities

This doesn't make it a crime-free utopia. It makes it a normal major city with typical urban safety considerations.

Personal Reflection

I've lived in Mexico City for over ten years. I've walked its streets at all hours, explored dozens of neighborhoods, attended events across the city, and built a life here. I've never been mugged, never been seriously threatened, never experienced the kind of random violence that makes you fundamentally question your safety.

I've had my phone stolen from my pocket on a crowded metro (classic pickpocketing), and I've seen sketch situations that I avoided by being aware of my surroundings. This is standard major city living, not evidence of unique danger.

Meanwhile, friends in U.S. cities tell me stories of carjackings, home invasions, random assaults—the kind of crime that happens in American cities but gets normalized rather than sensationalized.

Final Thoughts

Is Mexico safe? It depends on what you're comparing it to and where in Mexico you're talking about.

Mexico City is safer than many major U.S. cities by multiple statistical measures. It has standard urban crime that requires standard urban precautions. It doesn't have the random violence and petty crime of many American cities.

Certain parts of Mexico face serious cartel-related violence that creates genuine danger. Those regions deserve the travel advisories they receive.

But the blanket characterization of Mexico as uniformly dangerous is statistically false and perpetuated by media coverage that sensationalizes crime south of the border while normalizing comparable crime in the United States.

After a decade here, I can say confidently: Mexico City is a safe place to live and visit if you exercise normal urban precautions and choose your neighborhoods wisely. The crime statistics support this, and my lived experience confirms it.

The biggest danger might be believing the media narratives instead of looking at the actual data.

Related Mexico Safety Guides

Get city-specific safety information:

• Is Cancun Safe in 2026?
• Is Playa del Carmen Safe?
• Is Tulum Safe to Visit in 2026?
• Safe and Dangerous Areas in Mexico City

Related Mexico Safety Guides

• Explore Mexico City safely - services and resources
• Discover safe Cancun travel and activities
• Browse Playa del Carmen safety and services
• Read more Mexico safety and living guides

Travel or relocation service for Mexico? List your business on ExpatsList to help travelers and expats.