Best Pizza Restaurants in Playa del Carmen: Complete Guide

The best pizza in Playa del Carmen: Trattoria del Centro for authentic Neapolitan-style with legendary garlic oil, Don Chendo for Chicago deep-dish (the only legitimate deep-dish in town), and multiple Italian-owned pizzerias along 5th Avenue. Playa del Carmen has a serious pizza scene with wood-fired ovens, imported ingredients, and Italian expat chefs who take their craft seriously.

Top Pizza Restaurants in Playa del Carmen

1. Trattoria del Centro

Location: Calle 26 entre Avenida 5 y Avenida 10

Trattoria del Centro is known for freshly stone-baked dough and a signature garlic oil that's become legendary among local pizza lovers. The restaurant offers both traditional tomato-based pizzas and white-base options, giving you flexibility depending on your mood. Authentic Italian technique combined with quality ingredients makes this a top choice for traditional pizza that doesn't compromise on authenticity.

What sets Trattoria apart is their attention to dough. It's made fresh daily, allowed to properly ferment, and baked at the right temperature. The result is that perfect combination of crispy exterior and chewy interior that defines great pizza. Their garlic oil, drizzled at the table, elevates every slice. I always order extra on the side.

Specialty: Stone-baked pizzas, signature garlic oil, traditional and white-base options

Best for: Purists who want authentic Neapolitan-style pizza done right

2. Don Chendo

Location: Calle 24 y Avenida 30

Don Chendo specializes in Chicago-inspired deep-dish pizza with generous toppings and house-made tomato sauce. This is the only place in Playa where you can get legitimate deep-dish, and they execute it beautifully. The restaurant also offers gluten-free pizzas on Fridays for those with dietary restrictions, a thoughtful touch that expands their audience.

If you're from Chicago, or if you've ever had proper deep-dish and miss it, Don Chendo will feel like coming home. The crust is buttery and substantial, the cheese layer is generous, and the sauce on top has that characteristic sweetness balanced with acidity. Plan for a wait, deep-dish takes time to bake properly, and they don't rush it. The result is worth the patience.

Highlights: Chicago deep-dish, generous toppings, gluten-free options (Fridays)

Best for: Those craving hearty, filling pizza that's a meal unto itself

3. Sabrinas

Location: Two locations, Avenida Constituyentes (entre Avenida 10 y Avenida 15) and Avenida CTM (entre Avenida 20 y Avenida 25)

Sabrinas features thin crust pizzas with reasonable pricing that won't strain your wallet. The restaurant also offers pastries and coffee, making it a great spot for a casual meal or afternoon snack. Their Friday promotions include 50% off all pizzas, making it perfect for budget-conscious diners seeking quality pizza at unbeatable prices.

The two locations mean you're never far from a Sabrinas fix. The thin crust style is crispy and light, you can easily eat a whole pizza without feeling stuffed. That 50% Friday deal is genuinely excellent value, and locals know it, expect crowds. But the pizza quality doesn't suffer during promotions, which speaks to their consistency.

Specials: Thin crust pizzas, pastries, coffee, 50% off Fridays

Best for: Budget-conscious pizza lovers, casual dining, Friday night outings

4. Osteria del Roma

Location: Calle 6 entre Avenida 20 y Avenida 25

Osteria del Roma is known for gnocchi and rustic-style pizzas served on elongated platters that make for impressive presentations. The restaurant features Nutella dough balls for dessert that are dangerously addictive. This venue offers Italian authenticity with attention to detail in both pizza and pasta preparations.

The rustic style here means less precision, more character, irregular shapes, varied toppings, the feeling of something handmade rather than factory-produced. It's the kind of pizza you'd get at a family trattoria in Rome. And those Nutella dough balls? Order them. Trust me. They arrive warm, dusted with sugar, with molten Nutella inside. They've ruined other desserts for me.

Specialties: Rustic pizzas, house-made gnocchi, Nutella dough balls

Best for: Those seeking authentic Italian trattoria atmosphere and comfort

5. La Famiglia

Location: Calle 10 y Avenida 10

La Famiglia is an Italian-owned establishment offering thin crust pizzas with delivery and collection options available. The owners' passion for authentic Italian pizza shines through in every dish, you can tell this is personal for them, not just business. Perfect for both dine-in experiences and takeout when you want quality pizza at home.

Italian ownership matters For pizza, and La Famiglia proves it. The attention to ingredient quality, proper technique, and that intangible sense of care that family-run restaurants bring, it's all here. Their delivery is reliable, which makes them my go-to when I want great pizza without leaving my apartment. The crust arrives still crispy, which not all delivery pizza can claim.

Features: Thin crust pizzas, Italian-owned, delivery & collection options

Best for: Delivery pizza that doesn't compromise quality, convenient locations

Pizza Styles in Playa del Carmen

The pizza scene here is more diverse than you might expect:

• Neapolitan: Traditional thin crust with simple, quality toppings, found at Trattoria del Centro and La Famiglia
• Chicago Deep-Dish: Thick, hearty crust with generous fillings, exclusively at Don Chendo
• Rustic Italian: Artisanal approach with premium ingredients, Osteria del Roma's specialty
• Contemporary: Creative combinations with modern techniques, various spots experiment with fusion

Pizza Tips & Dining

To maximize your pizza experience in Playa:

• Visit during lunch for quieter dining and sometimes better service
• Most pizzerias accept delivery orders through WhatsApp, just ask
• Many restaurants offer family packages for group dining, better value
• Ask about daily specials and happy hour discounts, they're often not advertised
• Many use wood-fired ovens for authentic taste, you can usually see them working
• Reserve tables during weekends and tourist season, especially for dinner

Enjoying Pizza in Playa del Carmen

Whether you crave traditional Neapolitan pizza, hearty Chicago deep-dish, or creative modern combinations, Playa del Carmen's pizzerias deliver authentic Italian flavors and innovative twists in a beautiful beach setting. The combination of passionate pizza makers, fresh ingredients, and the relaxed Riviera Maya atmosphere makes for memorable meals. Now I'm hungry, time to call La Famiglia for delivery.

Related Playa del Carmen Dining Guides

• Best Vegan Restaurants in PDC
• All Food & Dining in PDC
• Food Delivery Apps in PDC

Own a pizzeria in PDC? List your restaurant on ExpatsList.