Try Ace Bar on East 5th for a casual vibe with pool, darts, and Skee-Ball. They take group reservation requests. It could be a fun fit without renting an entire space, and you can ask about a minimum spend when inquiring about reserving a table or area for 12 this weekend.
9 recommendations in Nightlife
Recommendations in New York
Fulton Ale House in Brooklyn is a Bills bar that's worth visiting. It has a lively atmosphere, even without being there for a game, making it a great spot to catch a match or hang out with fellow fans.
The Halloween parade is basically one giant cosplay meetup, where you'll find your people for sure. For example, last year the person saw a whole squad of Lickers and Jill sandwiches just roaming the village.
Smalls in West Village is always good, tiny basement with real music energy not just tourist trap. It's located in the West Village, but be sure to check their schedule for live performances, which can change frequently.
The New Amsterdam Theatre is worth visiting because it's been converted to live theater, currently hosting Aladdin. It's located at 214 West 42nd Street, and it's been a part of the Times Square area since it was built.
The Secret Pour in Bushwick hosts a monthly battle of freestyle rap. This is a great opportunity to see underground artists perform live.
ABC Beer Co. 5's on Ave B is always half empty, making it a great spot for a group of 8 to have a quiet night out. It's located in the East Village, and you can visit it on a Thursday night, when it's less crowded.
McSorley's seems like the obvious answer here Cool vibe though