Renting a Car in Cancun: The Reality Behind the Horror Stories (and the Best Rental Companies)

Yes, rent a car in Cancun, most rentals are uneventful despite online horror stories. Use EasyWay, America Car Rental, or National (less conspicuous than Hertz/Avis), drive conservatively, and document the car's condition with photos. Police shakedowns happen but aren't guaranteed. The drive from Cancun to Tulum is a straightforward highway. Here's how to rent safely.

The Real Situation

The internet makes car rental in Cancun sound terrifying. Police pulling people over for bribes, rental companies stealing deposits, gas station scams—it all sounds nightmarish. But here's the truth: most people who rent cars in Cancun have no problems whatsoever.

Many travelers report smooth rentals, zero police interactions, and full deposit returns. The key is knowing how to handle the real risks.

The Good News: What Usually Happens

• Most rentals are uneventful: Book online, pick up your car, drive, return it
• Deposits are typically returned: If you choose a reputable company and document the car's condition
• Police stops are not guaranteed: Many visitors drive extensively without any police interaction
• The drive from Cancun to Akumal/Tulum is straightforward: It's a well-traveled highway with clear signage
• Insurance is available and recommended: It protects you from unexpected damage claims

The Real Risks and How to Mitigate Them

Risk #1: Police Shakedowns (The Most Discussed Concern)

The Reality: Police do occasionally pull over rental cars, particularly from major international companies (which are obviously rental vehicles). However, this is not a guarantee—many visitors are never stopped.

Why They Target Rentals: Police know rental cars = tourists likely unfamiliar with local laws. They may claim minor violations (running a red light, speeding) to justify the stop.

How to Minimize This Risk:

• Drive conservatively: Follow speed limits strictly, stop fully at red lights, avoid erratic driving
• Avoid major rental brands at the airport: Hertz, Avis, Budget advertise themselves as rentals. Use companies like EasyWay, America Car Rental, or National which use less conspicuous vehicles
• Drive during daylight: Most police activity occurs at night or on certain roads
• Avoid common police hotspots: Bonampak Avenue is known for frequent stops
• Be prepared if stopped: Keep a small amount of cash (200-400 MXN/$10-20 USD) in your wallet separate from your main cash

If You Are Stopped:

• Remain calm and polite
• Ask to see the officer's badge and citation
• If you're confident you did nothing wrong, calmly say "No" when asked for payment
• Many officers will eventually leave if you don't immediately comply
• If they insist, the small cash you're carrying becomes the "resolution"
• Never hand over your license or documents as leverage
• Remember: this is business to them, not a safety threat to you

Risk #2: Rental Company Deposit Scams

The Reality: Some rental companies (notably Hertz) have been caught fabricating damage claims to keep deposits. However, most reputable companies return deposits without issue.

How to Protect Yourself:

• Document the car's condition thoroughly: Take video and photos of the entire exterior (including wheels, roof, undercarriage), interior, and any existing damage BEFORE driving off the lot
• Get a written inspection report: Have the rental agent sign off on the vehicle's condition at pickup
• Keep all receipts and documentation: Store everything digitally and physically
• Choose reputable companies: EasyWay, America Car Rental, National, Alamo, and Enterprise generally have better reputations than Hertz
• Book directly: Don't use aggregator websites; book directly with the rental company to ensure customer service recourse

Risk #3: Gas Station Scams

Common Tactics:

• Pump not reset to zero before filling—you're charged for previous customer's gas
• Attendant distracts you while charging your card twice
• Cash swapping: you hand them 500 pesos, they claim you handed them 100

How to Avoid This:

• Watch the pump: Verify it resets to zero before fuel starts flowing
• Don't let them distract you: Keep your eyes on the pump display the entire time
• Pay with cash when possible: Hand the attendant money and watch the transaction
• If using card: Watch the card the entire time and verify the final charge before signing
• Use major stations: PEMEX and Magna (the main chains) are more reliable than small independent stations

Risk #4: Insurance Pressuring and Hidden Costs

The Reality: Insurance adds significantly to rental costs, but it's often necessary because your personal car insurance likely doesn't cover Mexico.

Insurance Options:

• Rental company insurance: Most expensive but immediate coverage. Can range from $50-150+ per day
• Credit card coverage: Check your card before traveling. Some cards offer rental car protection that extends to Mexico
• Third-party insurance: Specialized Mexico car insurance (through companies like Allianz) is often cheaper than rental company coverage
• Book insurance in advance: Purchasing before arrival is usually cheaper than buying at the counter

Pro Tip: Get insurance. The cost of a major accident or liability claim is far more than the insurance premium. Your personal U.S. car insurance almost certainly doesn't cover Mexico.

Best Rental Car Companies (Based on Real Traveler Experiences)

Top Recommendations

EasyWay: Most consistently recommended. Smooth process, reasonable prices, shuttle from airport. Slightly older vehicles but reliable. Website: Direct booking available.

America Car Rental: All-inclusive pricing with insurance built in. No surprises at checkout. Very organized. Airport location available.

National/Alamo: Major international brands with better reputations than Hertz or Avis for Mexico operations. Good customer service if issues arise.

Value Car Rental: Excellent reviews. Excellent customer service. Non-descript vehicles (less obviously rental). Direct pickup/drop-off at some hotels.

Sixt and Enterprise: Solid options with generally positive feedback. Transparent pricing.

Royal Rent a Car: Highly praised for smooth transactions. Quick pickup/drop-off (under 3 minutes). No deposit required if you book correctly.

Companies to Avoid

Hertz: Multiple reports of fraudulent damage claims and forged insurance documentation. Very poor reputation for deposit returns.

Major brands (Avis, Budget, Hertz) at the airport: Not necessarily terrible, but their rental vehicles are obviously recognizable, which may increase police attention.

Booking Tips

• Book directly with the company: Not through Expedia, Kayak, or other aggregator sites. These often have hidden fees or inventory issues
• Book online and pay in advance: Lock in your rate and avoid upselling at the counter
• Avoid booking in December: Peak season means higher prices and fewer vehicle options
• Get full-coverage insurance: Either through the rental company or a third-party Mexico car insurance company
• Request a non-conspicuous vehicle: Ask for an older or standard-looking car rather than a new, clearly-rental vehicle
• Book one-way if needed: Returning to the airport rental location adds convenience

During Your Rental: Critical Steps

At Pickup

• Walk around the entire car with the agent while documenting condition
• Take detailed photos and video of exterior, interior, wheels, undercarriage, roof
• Point out any existing damage and have it documented on your contract
• Verify the spare tire, jack, and basic tools are present
• Check that the tank is actually full (don't rely on the gauge)
• Get a copy of everything you sign

While Driving

• Drive conservatively—follow all traffic laws strictly
• Avoid night driving if possible, especially on unfamiliar roads
• Watch for unmarked speed bumps ("topes")—they're everywhere and can cause serious damage
• Be extra careful in towns and residential areas where topes are frequent
• Keep insurance documents and rental agreement easily accessible
• Fill up gas tank completely before returning (you'll be charged inflated prices if you don't)

At Return

• Return the car in exactly the same condition as you received it (or document any changes)
• Fill tank completely at an external station, not the rental company's partner station
• Have the agent inspect the vehicle with you present
• Verify your inspection report before signing
• Take photos of the final inspection
• Get written confirmation that the car is damage-free and your deposit will be returned
• Keep all documentation for 30 days until charges stop appearing on your credit card

Speed Bumps: A Real Danger

This deserves special mention: topes (speed bumps) are everywhere in Mexico and often unmarked. They can cause serious suspension damage if hit at speed. Many accident claims come from tope damage, not traffic accidents.

• Slow down significantly when entering towns or populated areas
• Watch the road ahead for indicators of topes
• If you hit one at speed, get the damage documented immediately
• Understand that tope damage is often covered by insurance

The Akumal Route: Is It Safe?

The Cancun-to-Akumal drive is straightforward and well-traveled:

• Clear highway (Highway 307) all the way south
• Mostly well-maintained pavement
• Regular gas stations and rest areas
• Main tourist corridor, so relatively safe
• Watch for topes in small towns along the route
• Drive during daylight hours when possible

Most travelers report this drive is very manageable and uneventful.

Final Verdict: Should You Rent?

Yes, you should rent a car if you want to explore beyond the Hotel Zone. The risks are manageable with proper precautions. Thousands of people successfully rent cars in Cancun every year.

The key to success:

• Choose a reputable company (EasyWay, America Car Rental, National, Value)
• Book directly online in advance
• Get comprehensive insurance
• Document the car's condition meticulously
• Drive conservatively and follow traffic laws
• Watch for speed bumps
• Be prepared for potential police stops (but don't expect them)
• Keep small cash available just in case

Don't let online horror stories prevent you from exploring the Riviera Maya. Rent a car, enjoy the freedom, and drive safely.

Related Cancun Transportation Guides

• Cancun Airport to PDC Transport
• Visitax Guide
• Car Rental in PDC
• Services in Cancun

Offer car rental services? List your business on ExpatsList.