Fishs Eddy

For a unique and cute engagement gift, head to Fishs Eddy, a store that has a wide variety of kitchen knick-knacks, including cute little ceramic items like salt and pepper shakers.

While they may not specialize in vintage items, they have a great selection of affordable and adorable kitchen decor that's sure to please. You can find them on 25th Street in the Chelsea neighborhood, open on weekends.