Bilingual Siblings: Managing Language Preferences in Multilingual Families

Bilingual siblings often develop different language preferences even within the same family. One child might enthusiastically embrace multiple languages while another prefers only one, influenced by personality, age differences, school environment, and individual learning speeds. Research shows that children from multilingual families can differ dramatically in how they use languages, with some mixing languages deftly while others show only passive understanding of secondary tongues.

Families using multiple languages face unique challenges when raising more than one child. Language preferences of bilingual siblings can profoundly affect family dynamics, it's even possible that siblings might opt for a local language their expat parents don't speak fluently.

For expat families raising children abroad, ExpatsList connects you with international communities and resources worldwide.

Why Bilingual Siblings Develop Different Language Skills

Multilingual people differ in how and when they use a particular language; children are no different than adults in this regard. Within the same family, you'll find children who embrace languages wholeheartedly and others who are more reluctant. One child might absorb every language they're exposed to, another chooses a few, and the next prefers only one.

Suzanne Barron-Hauwaert's guide "Bilingual Siblings: Language Use in Families" explains how each child can get more or less out of a situation, even if the family shares the same experiences. This includes the languages the family uses. Sometimes families must adapt the language situation to the individual needs of each child.

Kids Learn Languages at Different Speeds

It's natural that children from different age groups are in different stages of language development. Those who are older often help younger ones develop language skills. However, older children sometimes use baby talk or very basic vocabulary with toddlers, which can affect language development patterns.

Some bilingual siblings mix all their languages fairly deftly and know precisely how to use a language's formalities at school. In most multilingual families, children are all at different stages of language development, this is perfectly natural.

Different Fluency Levels Within the Same Family

Some children work their way to fluency in multiple languages with ease. Others may only show passive understanding of one language, responding in another common language. Bilingual or multilingual children often mix up syntactic structures of languages, especially if the languages are related (such as English and German).

This affects conversations within the family considerably. As a parent, the best strategy is ensuring you subtly prompt children to use languages correctly. There's no need to scold a child for linguistic mistakes, but gentle corrections help.

Emerging Language Preferences in Bilingual Siblings

It's not uncommon for a young child to refuse speaking in a certain language, even if they're perfectly capable. This isn't a signal of parental failure or rebellious behavior, it just means your child is thinking for themselves.

As a parent, it's important not to force a language if children are resisting. Just like adults, tastes change over time, extending to the languages people use. All you can (and should) do is ensure your child's linguistic toolbox is as full as possible. In time, they'll appreciate the ability to speak another language.

Respecting Individual Language Choices

Linguistic preferences of bilingual siblings are bound to differ as they grow older. Not everyone is interested in becoming a polyglot. Even functional ability to speak two languages gives any child a dramatic advantage once they become an adult.

If one child isn't nearly as keen as their siblings to use multiple languages daily, the family needs to respect that choice. For discipline or serious discussions, it's beneficial to pick a language and stick with it. This way, kids understand that a shift in language means a shift in tone and topic (plus the added benefit of sharpening skills in an underused tongue).

External Factors Affecting Language Preferences

In many multilingual families, personality is the most important factor impacting languages used. Multilingual expat families might speak anywhere between two to four languages daily. The language combinations for each family member might differ as well.

School and Social Influences

Children will generally decide at a very early stage which languages they prefer speaking, though external factors like classmates at school affect this for every family member. Some siblings might even opt for a language that neither parent speaks well, perhaps due to school's influence on their everyday lives.

Having an au pair around the house or moving abroad again can sometimes throw additional languages and variables into the mix. Expat families need to foster and encourage language learning for their bilingual children while respecting individual preferences.

Practical Strategies for Multilingual Families

• Avoid forcing language use: Respect children's emerging preferences while maintaining exposure to all family languages
• Gentle correction over scolding: Provide subtle prompts when children mix languages incorrectly rather than harsh criticism
• Consistent language for serious topics: Use the same language for discipline and important discussions to create clear associations
• use older siblings: Encourage older children to help younger ones, but monitor for over-simplified "baby talk"
• Adapt to individual needs: Recognize that each child's linguistic journey differs and adjust expectations accordingly
• Maintain exposure: Even if a child resists a language, continue exposure so the skill remains available later in life

Studycat: Making Language Learning Fun for Kids

Looking for a lively way to get your kids excited about language learning? Studycat is an online learning platform with award-winning, engaging programs that make language learning colorful and fun. Choose from five of the world's most spoken languages and start your children on the right track towards bilingualism.

For families raising multilingual children abroad, explore ExpatsList's guides on international education for comprehensive resources on expat family life.